People of color have certainly gained equality (or probably majority) in sport as far as numbers in physical presence and athletic opportunities. However, the same cannot be said about opportunities for people of color in upper management/ownership and coaching in sports. One of the most important developments in this decade for race equality was the inception of the “Rooney Rule” (named after the Steelers’ owner) in the NFL in 2003, which requires NFL teams to interview minority candidates for head coaching jobs.
This article on the subject by Dave Goldberg describes the impact of the Rooney Rule on the NFL. He talks about how the other leagues have fared and the impact on the front offices as well.
“While the NFL hasn't achieved the coaching diversity of other sports leagues--the NBA has had double-digit numbers of black coaches for a decade, Major League Baseball has nine black, Hispanic or Asian managers for 30 teams--the Rooney Rule seems to have inspired minority hires not only on the sidelines but in the front offices. The rule does not apply to top executive hires, but the number of black general managers has increased from one in 2002 to five now. Just as important is the success of minority coaches and GMs: five of the six teams in the last three Super Bowls have had either black coaches or general managers.”
It is interesting to note that the NFL is a sport dominated in numbers by African American athletes, yet the coaching numbers don’t reflect that quite as much as in the NBA, which is in a similar situation of proportion of African American athletes (although the NBA has had higher percentage of minority coaches).
In the article Racial Integration of Coaching by Goff and Tollison, they address the percentage issue: “Black players make up 65% of the workforce in the NFL. Some writers in the media and in economics have used this figure as a benchmark by which to judge hiring of Black coaches. The backgrounds of NFL coaches indicates that past NFL playing experience is not necessarily a strong influence on the hiring of coaches; therefore, the 65% benchmark may not be relevant” (Goff & Tollison, 138).
It is also an interesting concept because race is a social construction. “For Max Weber, there was race only if there was a race consciousness anchored in a community identity which could lead to action, such as segregation or prejudice. These were not necessarily attributable to hereditary differences but to habitus” (Jarvie, Handbook, 335). The problem of having a lack of minority coaches in professional sports was something created by us, and something that required us to create rules to fix it.
So, I pose these questions. Is the Rooney Rule out-dated, or should it continue to be implemented at the same or even a higher level? Should such rules be extended to upper management? Should percentages of athletes in the sport play a role in requirements? Should teams be allowed to interview whoever they want, or should they have to comply because they all fall under the law of the NFL?
Showing posts with label NFL. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NFL. Show all posts
Monday, November 16, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)